Pinto beans stewed with cilantro and bay

Extreme closeup on pinto beans stewed with cilantro and bay: orangey-pink beans and light yellow rice fill the entire frame, all festooned with chopped herbs and crumbled cheese

In the two or three weeks this recipe has been sitting in the hopper, waiting for me to write the blog post and put in pretty pictures, I’ve been trying to remember why and when I first made it. And — sorry to disappoint — I just can’t! It’s adapted from a decade-old post on Smitten Kitchen, with no pictures of the food; I suspect I maybe saw it in one of Deb’s “x years ago” recipe headnotes, and was intrigued by “Dominican beans.”

Dominican beans, an orangey-pink stew inside an enameled cast iron Dutch oven. The beans contrast with the cream-colored interior, which itself stands out from the dark blue of the pot's exterior, and its lid leaning against it.

Because, you see, I eat a lot of beans, as I’m pretty sure I’ve mentioned. Those recipes don’t usually make it onto the site, because they’re pretty basic, workaday pots o’ beans, made to be stashed in the fridge and doled out with some rice for weekday lunches. (What’s more, I often find myself making them as an afterthought after sundown when the kitchen’s a complete wreck, which isn’t the most inviting photographic environment.)

A closeup of pinto beans stewed with cilantro and bay, flecked with bits of chopped cilantro sprinkled over the top. Light yellow rice sits alongside the beans, in slightly unfocused in the background.

But Dominican beans… I don’t really know from Dominican cooking, except for some bits of embarrassingly  vague knowledge about pan-Caribbean foodways. So I suspect when I saw that recipe title I just had to know what was up. And when I did look, the recipe was so intriguing! Most of the bean recipes I cook hail from the Southwestern U.S., and I hadn’t previously realized how that limited my  ideas of what a pot of beans ‘should’ taste like: heavy on pork and chiles, boldly flavored and spicy.

A small wooden bowl filled with pinto beans, flanked by a light green Anaheim pepper and a dark-green bunch of cilantro: yeeeeesss

But these beans are something else entirely: my beloved pinto beans are there, yes, and all the seasonings are familiar and ordinary, but the way they’re deployed is terribly different from my expectations, more subtle and almost delicate. There’s chile, but instead of a robust dried red ancho or guajillo, or a smoky, fiery chipotle en adobo, it’s an Anaheim chile, pale green and sprightly fresh. There’s tomato, but it’s far out of the spotlight, just a background supporting player. There’s cilantro, but it’s stewed so thoroughly that its bright flavor, usually prominent, fades to a background layer.

Closeup on pinto beans stewed with cilantro and bay, with light yellow rice in the background; the whole plate is strewn with chopped cilantro and crumbled cotija cheese

Instead, the flavor that comes out front is, of all things, bay. (Yes, I’m still on a bay kick.) With all the other flavorings dialed back, bay leaf’s citrusy minerality gets to shine out front, playing off the richness of the pinto beans in a back and forth that’s intensely satisfying. Paired with some lightly flavored rice, this is a brown-bag lunch that I’m always very happy to eat. It’ll never replace the pinto beans of my childhood, but this dish taught me some new things about how to eat beans, and it has a permanent place in my rotation.

A light blue plate filled with light yellow rice and orangey-pink pinto beans stewed with cilantro and bay, seen from overhead. The whole plate is sprinkled with dark-green flecks of chopped cilantro and bright white crumbles of cheese.

Pinto beans stewed with cilantro and bay

  • Servings: 6-8
  • Print

These beans have been a very welcome variation to my bean rotation ever since I first tried them. If you, like me, are accustomed to the bold and spicy pinto beans of Texas and the Southwestern U.S., do yourself a favor and give these a try: spicy flavors take a backseat, and the warming complexity of bay leaf gets to come to the fore and play with the richness of the beans themselves. 

Adapted from Gourmet‘s “Dominican Beans,” Nov. 2006, by way of smitten kitchen


1 lb. pinto beans
1 med. white onion, diced
3 cloves garlic, minced
1 Anaheim chile, seeded and diced
1 c finely chopped cilantro leaves and stems (about half a bunch)
2 bay leaves
1/2 tsp dried oregano
1/2 tsp ground black pepper
1 tsp kosher salt
3 Tbsp tomato paste
1 Tbsp white vinegar

Cooked rice, to serve (I made this alongside bay leaf rice, which was a beautifully aromatic combination)


Soak the beans in well-salted water. You can do this overnight in room temperature water, or you can bring them to a boil, then let them sit for an hour or so for a quick-soak. Either way, drain them before moving on.

In a large pot over medium-high heat, saute the onions in the olive oil until they are somewhat soft and turning translucent, about five minutes. Add the garlic and saute for another minute or so.

Add the drained beans and the chile, cilantro, bay, oregano, pepper, and salt, as well as enough water to cover (about 5 cups). Bring to a boil, then reduce heat to very low and simmer until the beans are tender, about an hour.

Add the tomato paste and vinegar and simmer another twenty minutes or so, until the broth has thickened and become almost creamy. Taste and adjust seasoning, then serve as a side dish, or as a simple dinner with rice.


The original Gourmet recipe lists two bean options: pintos and pink beans (aka habichuelas rosadas). Pink beans would indeed be lovely here, as would light red beans (not the deep maroon ones; the flavor’s just not right.)

If you’d like, you can used 3 cans of beans instead of starting from dry. Just rinse and drain them, and then begin by sauteing the onions. You won’t need to simmer for a whole hour, since the beans are already cooked, but give it a good 20-30 minutes so the chile and cilantro have time to stew thoroughly.

Garnishes! I’ll admit that I originally sprinkled cotija cheese in these pictures simply for the visual interest, but it turns out that a sprinkle of salty, crumbly cheese melds very well with these beans, so I recommend that, as well as some chopped fresh herbs.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s